top of page

[REVIEW] 'Don't Tell Mom the Babysitter's Dead': Reliving Nostalgia or Repackaging Stereotypes?

The entertainment industry has long capitalized on the notion that nostalgia sells. The recent upsurge in reboots and remakes taps into our collective yearning for the familiar, with a twist of contemporary relevance. This phenomenon has given birth to a reimagined version of the 1991 cult classic, "Don't Tell Mom the Babysitter's Dead," now repackaged by BET+ Studios and presented to a new audience. The revival of this treasured commodity offers a multifaceted conversation about cultural adaptation, audience reception, and the impact of representation in the reboots of yesteryear's hits.

The return of "Don't Tell Mom the Babysitter's Dead", Directed by newcomer Wade Allain-Marcus, stirs a blend of excitement and skepticism. Fans of the original have waited to see if the remake would capture the adventurous essence they cherished. However, this adaptation was not without criticism, particularly regarding how cultural elements are portrayed.

They go out of their way to make sure that audiences know that this is a "black version" to the franchise. Stereotypes are thrown all over the screen, along with an excessive use of the "N Word" in order to relate with its target audience and to distinguish itself through the lens of a Black family. While representing a diverse range of experiences is valuable, the danger lies in relying on stereotypes, potentially detracting from the characters' authenticity.

The discourse around cultural representation demonstrates a broader societal craving for content that accurately reflects a variety of experiences without resorting to one-dimensional portrayals. The BET remake attempts to straddle this fine line, offering a new perspective while inadvertently stirring discomfort over a huge portion of the films first 30 minutes. I sat through the first half of the film extremely disappointed.

Modern Twists and Fresh Faces

Amidst revisiting the familiar plot, the remake introduces new elements and characters designed to captivate contemporary viewers. A major component to highlight is the portrayal of new colorful characters and relationships that deviate from the original script.

For example; Tanya 'Suellen' Crandell, the lead played by Simon Joy Jones (Bel-Air), now has a tween-ish year old younger sister who is a gothic, computer hacking, gamer with international connections via her Girlfriend and or her Boyfriend if she should ever need criminal assistance. Jones' other two siblings are Kenny (Donnielle Hansley), The second oldest, Hip-Hop Skater boy blend complete with dreads, gold grills and skateboard. And then theres Zack, (Carter Young), who is clearly the most mature and common sensed of the bunch, yet almost too awkward and nerdy to not laugh at. I did however love Nicole Richie. Richie plays Rose the Fashion mogul originally played by Joanna Cassidy...and she does a really cool job at it. She really kind of grounds things in a nostalgic way, she's funny and one of the stronger casting choices to breathe new life into this reimagined role. But even through these performances, the butt of the jokes are always heavily reliant on racial stereotypes as they try to avoid the fool-proof blueprint that has already been laid out for them.

The Reboot's Reception and Cultural Context

The verdict on any film—original or retold—is ultimately passed through the collective reception of its audience. The remake's faithfulness to its precursor towards the second half of the film and its refreshing conclusion contribute to a complex viewing experience.

I really love the ending. I feel like the ending of this one is a lot more satisfying than the ending to the original. A fitting conclusion can leave a lasting impression, highlighting a better mending of differences and understanding ones choice as well as showcasing a more rewarding payoff. This really speaks to how the creative team's decisions inform the legacy of the remake.

Overall, the reimagined "Don't Tell Mom the Babysitter's Dead," with its moments of discomfort and delight, invites viewers to assess the delicate craftsmanship involved in reboots, and how well they honor their predecessors while carving out their own space within the cultural zeitgeist. "Don't Tell Mom the Babysitters's Dead" prompts extensive consideration of cultural representation and storytelling evolution. As the industry continues to delight in repurposing the classics, we just hope thy can manage to bridge yesteryear's magic with today's diversified audience, crafting a space where the legacy of nostalgia can entertain and inspire with renewed relevance, without coming off so basic.

For a more visual review:


bottom of page